Flann sees ice in the rain

“Sister!”
Flann moaned.
“Sister! Let me up!” Cat pounded the quilts with the flat of her hand. “I’m thinking Paul’s here!”
Flann rolled onto her side and burrowed her cheek into the pillow. “Fie, and if he is? It won’t kill him to sleep one night without you.”
It certainly had not killed Osh so far.
“But he’s hurting! There’s something wrong with him! Sister!”
Flann’s throat tightened. “How are you knowing that?”
“I can feel it! Ach, let me up, Flann!”
Cat shoved Flann’s shoulder hard enough to squash her sore breasts. Flann flipped back the quilts and slung the pile onto Cat’s lap.

“Fine! I’m letting you up! Are you glad? But you’re not getting back in afterwards, if it isn’t he! Find your own bed! Not a wink have I slept tonight!”
Flann stumbled out into the cold room and turned to address the billowing bed curtains, proclaiming the many indignities done her as loudly as she dared.
“First we had to come here – in the rain! – right after I had put Liadan down, and she thinking it’s morning time again! And as soon as she’s sleeping and I’m crawling into bed, you would be waking me to let you up to pee! And then she waking me to let her nurse!”
Cat whimpered behind the curtain as she struggled with the blankets.
“And now you again, telling me Paul is here! And if he isn’t? What next? Colin opening the wrong door and crawling in on top of me?”
Cat’s feet thumped onto the rug, and belly-first she emerged from the tangle of curtains. “He is here! I’m swearing it! I can feel him!”

Flann choked. Loneliness was the only thing she felt when her husband went out. She wondered whether he even thought of her when he was away.
Cat squinted her eyes and squeezed bunched-up handfuls of her nightgown in her fists. Flann had the unsettling thought that Cat’s “feelings” might rather have something to do with the baby. She had been sweaty and restless all evening long.
“Help me, Flann!” she panted. “Something has happened to him!”

Cat had long insisted that her baby was a wee girl – but who could say how mothers knew what they knew?
Flann brushed a damp curl off her sister’s cheek. “Happened to whom, darling?”
“To Paul!”
Flann stamped her bare foot and sighed. “Calm yourself, sister! What could have happened to him? Mayhap Cousin Malcolm threw the first punch and blacked the eye of him. Even he could never get a second blow in on an elf. And Osh wouldn’t let them fight. I wager your man’s only sulking so hard you can hear him pouting from here. Mayhap Osh let Malcolm kiss her again, and Paul’s sore.”
Flann tittered, but Cat moaned and ran for the door, staggering like a bewitched woman dragged by unseen hands. Flann’s scalp prickled.

In a low voice she warned, “Wait for him here, Cat. You cannot be gadding about the house in your nightgown. Are you wanting to run into Colin?”
Cat yanked back the latch and opened the door.
“In the dark? Sister?”
Cat disappeared into the stark blackness of the hallway.
Flann dashed a few steps after her and stopped. “Ach! Let me get a candle, at least!”
She took the candle from Liadan’s bedside table and prayed the baby would not notice.
By the time she stepped into the hallway, Cat was no more than a whimpering echo and a flicker of gloom in the darkness. She turned the corner and vanished like a ghost.
“Ach, Cat! Not the stairs!”
Flann cupped her hand around the candle and ran. The guttering flame shrank to a pinprick of light by the time she reached the stairs, and she had to feel her way down with her bare feet. She told herself Osh would be there to catch her if she fell. She told herself she felt his reassuring presence below.
As Cat turned the corner below her she heard Paul wail, “Naí, naí!”
Cat’s scuffing footsteps stopped. Flann stumbled out behind her and lowered her hand.

The candle flame throbbed and grew tall again. Flann looked around the hall. A dark-haired, rain-soaked someone stood with Paul before the fire, but that someone was not Osh. Osh was not there at all.
Cat whimpered, “Paul?”
A wave of darkness rolled across the room, snuffing out all fire and all light. Cat shrieked.

A voice from beside the hearth scolded, “Paul!”
A wave of light burst from the fireplace: logs and lamps and wicks leapt into flame as far as torchères against the wall that had not been lit before.
Flann’s candle flared and spat a mist of wax across the back of her hand. She drew back her head and howled in fright.
“What’s the matter with you, Paul? Are you trying to burn my face?”

Paul moaned. Cat shuffled around the bench to meet him, blubbering.
Flann set her candle on the high cabinet and stopped within its sheltering globe of light, at a few steps’ distance from the scene.
Now she recognized the elf with Paul. Tashnu never seemed at ease among them, never forgot his visits were a crime. This was the first time Flann had seen him without his brother Shosudin or Vash, and she thought this an ominous sign.

She rolled her tongue around her mouth and watched him attempt to wordlessly comfort Cat and Paul while holding them apart with both hands. His wet hair flung off drops of rain that zigzagged down his wrinkled forehead and into his brows.
Flann opened her lips and whispered, “Sipú síkhírrí líhérí alúrí, Tashnú.”

Tashnu’s mouth fell open, and he stared bug-eyed at Cat before he thought to look past her to Flann. He closed his mouth, and the wrinkles of his forehead softened. He whispered something, but she could not read the elven language on his lips. “May sunlight surround you, Flann,” she filled in for him.
For a moment Cat’s panicked babbling and Paul’s whimpers were no more than the drumming of rain to two people who have dashed for shelter and found it beneath the same roof. She told herself she could feel something in Tashnu’s presence that was like Osh’s presence – that there was something in Osh’s presence that she could feel.
She whispered, “Alla…”

She could not finish her question. Would an elven wife need to ask where her husband was? An elven wife would simply feel it. Perhaps Osh would be ashamed if Tashnu knew she did not.
Cat saved her by grabbing Paul’s belt with both hands and wailing, “Look at me, love! What’s happened to you?”
Tashnu dashed back into the storm and pulled them apart, stuttering half-formed English phrases right and left.
Flann leaned against the cabinet. Her legs trembled like tent poles bearing up a lake of rain. Already trickles of fear were leaking in. Where was Osh? He had left in the company of Paul, and hours later Paul had returned without him, distraught, in the company of Tashnu alone…
Behind her she heard floorboards creak beneath the pounding of bare feet, and out of old habit she jolted upright and tried to look innocent. Even before her bouncing hair had settled she recalled that no nighttime frolics would wake her angry father ever more. Dead, too, dead…
Aengus whipped back the curtain and pounded down the steps into the hall.

“What in the devil is going on in here?”
Cat sobbed, “Aengus!”
Flann smudged away a tear.

Aengus stomped around the bench. “Is anyone unconscious or bleeding? For otherwise, I don’t want to hear about it!”
Paul shouted, “Yes!”
Aengus stopped so short he nearly lost his balance. Flann grabbed the arm he put out to steady himself.

Osh! She could not take a breath to ask. She could only cling.
Cat yanked at Paul’s belt again. “Paul! Look at me! Are you hurt? Are you bleeding?”
Tashnu looked between Aengus and Flann. “You do not know?”
Aengus took a deep breath and stood tall, dragging Flann up with him. “Know what, for the love of Christ? Will somebody stop blubbering long enough to tell me what is happening here?”
Paul bent his forehead to the mantel top and sobbed as elves did: silently but powerfully. Osh sometimes crushed the very breath out of Flann when she tried to dry his tears.
He crushed her, too, when he kissed away her own – and when he greeted her with a hug, and when he laughed with her and danced her around, and most of all when he loved her. He crushed her to his chest and made her breathe against his throat in shallow gasps, like a panting bird, until she cried out, and he melted.

But now her fear crushed her like a fledgling sparrow in its fist, and she could not breathe at all. Her weight dragged at Aengus’s arm.
He glanced down at her, and his dark eyes flashed with understanding. Whatever he had begun to say turned into: “And where is Osh, first of all?”
Tashnu said, “Not Osh is hurt. Lasrua is hurt.”
Flann took a ragged breath. Aengus slipped his arm around her and helped her stand.
Tashnu frowned and turned such a dark look onto the back of Paul’s head that every gaze followed his. Fat drops of rain swelled at the tips of Paul’s wet hair and dripped onto his collar.
Cat whimpered, “Rua’s hurt?”
Flann’s relief retreated like a breaking wave. Her husband was not hurt – but his daughter was. Osh must have spent the night in anguish, and she had felt nothing at all: only annoyance that he had left her to spend another night alone. He would be heartbroken if he knew. Perhaps he did know. An elven wife would have gone forth to find him in the dark and the rain.
Paul pressed his forehead to the mantel and breathed in silent sobs. His shoulders writhed beneath his wet cloak. Tashnu laid a hand upon one of them and pulled, turning him around to face the family.
“Tell them, Paul.”
Paul tipped back his head. His dripping hair clung to his scalp, giving him a look of baby-like fragility, but the sinister points of his ears pierced through.
“May God forgive me! I spilled the blood of my sister!”
Cat screamed and grasped the edge of the mantel.

Aengus asked, “Is she badly hurt?”
Tashnu patted Cat’s shoulder with an awkward hand and shook his head at Aengus. “We do not know. Did you hear no message?”
Cat screamed again.
Aengus said, “No, no message – a message from whom?”
Cat sucked in another breath and screamed.

Aengus shouted at her in Gaelic: “Cousin! Calm yourself! At least until we learn what happened.”
As soon as Cat pulled another breath into her lungs, she shrieked again. Flann hugged her from behind, sliding her hands around her belly to hold the baby. Cat’s knees folded beneath her, and she sank towards the floor, dragging Flann down.
Flann looked beside her for help. “Aengus!”
Aengus and Tashnu stepped forward, but Paul had felt his wife falling, and Cat had felt him reaching out to safely catch her.
No one reached for Flann.
Paul’s slitted eyes squinted shut at the sound of her knees hitting the floor, but for an instant, as she fell through his blank gaze, she saw what her sister must have seen: two dull white orbs of ice in a face that sparkled with rain and tears.



34 Comments
Hide Comments
Add a comment
Hoooooooo boy. I kind of doubt even Aelfden can pull that sort of stunt twice. Looks like Paul's never going to see his baby. Poor Cat
Aengus! It's been two days and he looks ten years older! I didn't even recognize him at first
Priests in the banner? That's not a good sign...
Whoah! I... Did not see that coming.
Holy crap! I've been online all day downloading stuff and I completely failed to notice this until I loaded the comments page for a chapter I had finished rereading hours ago and saw Pen's "Whoah! I did not see that coming" and then I was all
"What happened???"
Ach, poor Flann. Things with Osh are clearly not working out very well, and she's so insecure. It worries me that she thinks about Colin finding her in the dark, too.
And Paul!
I suppose this is his punishment for spilling elven blood again?
Though, last time he was blind, he had killed someone...
Oh, and this:
Is that a mistake or is my English failing me?
It's interesting to see Tashnu out in English-speaking world. And Paul... I don't know, will he become more calm now or even more crazy rage-filled?
I feel really bad for Flann; she seemed like such a harlot flirting with her two cousins (whose names I've forgotten) but now that we get her POV again we can see how she's really feeling.
It certainly had not killed not Osh so far.
typo
Oh my, oh my.
I was wondering about the consequences of Paul spilling Rua's blood. We don't know how the blinding is done - it seems it's an inescapable consequence. Except for the time Vash cut himself on purpose...so maybe not.
Once again, I am at odds with the feelings of the crowd, because my feelings for Flann were not sympathy but irritation. It was amazing how much time she found to feel sorry for herself in the midst of a situation that was not directly about her at all. She's jealous of Cat's pain, for heaven's sake. I guess I don't have a lot of patience for insecurity (especially since she's married to a very reassuring guy, one or two conversations with him ought to clear this up).
Poor Cat, I felt the worst for her. Paul brought it on himself.
Oh, God.
What miserable people.
Poor Cat. I can't imagine what Paul will be like now, or how much he might spiral out of control...
I really do feel for Cat she's lost her home, her closest friend Lena to a witch and now this.
I also feel for Paul to everything is piling up on him.
Thank you, O mistake-finding people.
maruutsu, last time Paul was blinded he hadn't killed. He was blinded for attempting to kill Malcolm. His crime was spilling the blood of an elf, since Malcolm had a drop or two of elven blood in his veins. That was enough to damn him.
As for Flann -- yes, she is very insecure right now. I don't blame her too much. She had hoped to find peace in her marriage, but she's had so much turmoil. There have been all the dramas with Sebastien, Kraaia, Lasrua, Lena, Maire and Aengus, Lugaid and Ferdie, Colin hanging around (and perhaps harassing Flann, since she seems kind of worried about his presence, as maruutsu noted), and... what have I missed? Connie being ill and young Malcolm turning into a dick about it and keeping her away from Cat and Flann. The stifling false-festive atmosphere at Nothelm, where she's been living much of the time since her marriage, up until the last few days when she FINALLY got to move into her new house with Osh. (And then right away she gets packed off to Aengus's house to sleep again.)
Flann hasn't been at the center stage of any of these dramas, but to some extent that's part of the problem. Since nothing is acutely wrong with her, she gets left alone a lot, and packed off here and there to keep her safe while Osh is busy. A few days at Nothelm, a few days at Aengus's, etc., with Osh going in and out. She scarcely knows where she'll be sleeping more than a day or two ahead of time, and it seems like Osh can get called away at any time.
What Flann and Osh both need is a honeymoon. Osh has been so busy dealing with other people's problems. They need to have some time alone to just be with each other and Liadan. They got married in the middle of a crisis, and it's been mostly non-stop crisis since then.
I think Osh is actually quite good at just BEING WITH HER when he is with her, but Flann needs huge quantities of being-with right now, to top her off again. Scarcely more than a month ago she was suicidal.
She also has a huge insecurity about the nature of her marriage to Osh. Lydia, she isn't jealous of Cat's pain exactly -- she's jealous that Cat can feel it. It's like a sterile woman being jealous of another woman's labor pains. I know you know that, but it's important to make the distinction. She wants a love like the one Cat and Paul share.
And more important than her own feelings is her greater fear that Osh isn't going to be satisfied with her the way she is and with their marriage the way it is. She's afraid Osh won't feel like they're really married. It's obviously bothering Osh at least a little bit since he blew up over it in "Paul speaks a secret".
So yeah. Insecurity. Flann has it.
Do you think I overstated her own private fears? I mean, we know that Rua is the one who is injured, but Flann didn't know that until about four-fifths of the way through the chapter. All she knows is:
Paul isn't visibly wounded himself, and Flann's accustomed to his and Cat's extravagant shows of emotion by now. She's a sleep-deprived, insecure young lady who has lost the two men she loved most in less than a year -- the death or injury of Osh (all the more terrifying since she can't feel anything) seems like the first thing that would come into her mind. What comes into your mind when the phone rings at 2 AM? Wrong number?
I tried to show Flann going from a self-centered "never killed Osh so far" griping, to a visceral fear that she has just lost the guy who picks her up and dances her around and squeezes her until she squeaks. Hopefully the first part didn't overwhelm the last. She does love Osh. She's just afraid of losing him.
To my mind, the person who needs to get over himself in this chapter is Paul. Even Flann's most self-pitying moments are nothing next to his what-have-I-done wailing. And hiding his face from Cat like that, and blowing out the lights. I'm so disgusted with Paul and the depths of his wallowing right now. And he has done worse than you know yet.
And the person I pity the most (of the people here) is Cat. She is having an awful, awful month. Lost her friends Lena and Maire and Egelric, lost her house, possibly lost her sister-in-law, and now her husband has lost his sight again. Even Aengus is partly to blame for what happened to him, but Cat has done NOTHING to deserve this. And woe-is-me Paul is not thinking about her at all in this chapter. *kicks Paul*
Not to mention the tiny, insignificant detail that she was gang-raped.
Dear, poor Cat
Then Rua isn't dead, says I.
But if spilling another elf's blood is enough to blind you, what does actually murdering another elf do to you?
I'm really curious about this whole you-hurt-an-elf-we-hurt-you business. Obviously it doesn't happen among the kisor, or between kisor-khirron elves. And it's clearly related to blood -- as it's an important part to their magic, what with the whole binding thing -- so rape doesn't count, no? I'm guessing it has more to do with intentionally hurting someone of your own blood, someone who's on your same "side", so to speak.
Well, I actually got goosebumps when Cat started screaming. And yes, Paul definitely needs to get his act together a bit and start realizing that he is not alone. What is it with my usually favorite male characters acting like fools lately? Disheartening, I tell you. Also, I am getting a feeling of foreboding with Cat and Paul's child. If Paul has done worse...what if there was some way that Paul's curse is automatically and magically transferred to his offspring? I really do feel most for Cat here.
Wow, so the spell can rebound? I did not expect that. But Paul deserves it. My pity for him is all gone.
There is more?? Oh Paul, what else have you done, you sniffeling little drama-elf?? Gah, I can't even begin to imagine.
I'm happy that we got a look into Flann's head again, because I was getting annoyed with her and I didn't like it. I should be able to understand her, dammit! But now I'm glad. And I think you did her and the situation justice, Jenny.
Poor Cat. I hope she isn't losing the baby? Oh please, no!
And Rua can't die! Because I says so! *pout*
Is it just me, or does Matthew look somewhat Vash-like in that banner?
I knew something like that must have happened to Paul ! But is this an automatic punishment for elves ? When they spill elves blood, they are blind ? Or is that some elf magic ? If so, who did it ? Osh, punishing is son ? I don't think so ...
I'm so angry against Paul too. He doesn't see (haha, very relevant here) his pregnant wife having an awful life right now. As for the house, whom is it ? I'm a bit confused.
It's Aengus's house, I think.
Now that you mention it, Van, he does look a bit like Vash! It must be the pouty, emo-Peter-Pan expression on his face.
Damn, some people need a break from the non-stop drama train of doom. However it keeps the story riveting...good job.
Also thanks for the 12th pic down!
Paul's blindness is not an "automatic" consequence of spilling an elf's blood. I mean, legally it is, but it doesn't spontaneously happen. There's some sort of ceremony or at least deliberate action involved. Paul hinted about this in "The elf falls back on memories":
So last time it was done in Sorin's chamber, presumably by Sorin himself. It's a punishment, not a curse.
There is a sort of curse involved too, but that's not related to the blinding. The elves believe Paul is damned now (and was already for what he did to Malcolm). So he's "cursed" insofar as he will go to elven hell. But as far as anyone knows it will have no effect on the baby. The baby is in more danger from Cat's physical condition right now. She needs a vacation too.
The crime Paul committed is, very literally, spilling an elf's blood. "An elf" of course refers to a khírrón. We are beginning to see that the elves have a lot of laws, rituals, and taboos related to blood. There is the exchanging-blood form of the binding ceremony. There is the dire law against spilling blood that Paul has broken twice now. And Lena freaked out when Kraaia suggested that she consumed blood, even accidentally.
I might as well throw in the fact that Surr and Mash were killed in a bloody fashion, whereas the elves who killed them could have easily killed them with magic and not wasted two arrows. The khírrón are forbidden from spilling each others' blood, but it appears to be "the thing" to kill the kisór in that way.
I've not finished revealing this particular aspect of elven society, so I won't say any more for now. I just wanted everyone to be aware that the blinding didn't magically, spontaneously happen to Paul tonight. Somebody did it to him as punishment.
François, the house is indeed Aengus's. Cat and Paul have been living there since their house burned.
But Osh wouldn't do that, right? Or Vash.
Does the blinding have something to do with what happened before Malcolm's exchange with Sigefrith?
I feel bad for Paul; he can't control himself and now he's cursed. But the real victim here (other than Rua) is Cat, of course.
Hmm, we need a Vash/Kraaia chapter to explain this whole thing to us.
Haha, Kraaia's POV would be awesome here. She would grab Vash by the tip of the ear and demand "WHAT is the MATTER with you people? It was an accident!"
And then she would kick Paul for me.
You mean like... the whole stabbing-his-sister something?
I don't understand the question.
Oh, I thought Flann was perfectly entitled to feel frantic with worry over Osh; that's only natural. The bit I found distasteful on her part was all the self-pity over not being a real elven wife. In the midst of such chaos going on, noticing that no one reached for her when she fell seemed a little much. That, and when Cat was trying to tell her that something was wrong with Paul she couldn't take her seriously because she was too busy resenting their connection, so she minimized it. I don't think any of that makes her a bad person, or unbelievable, but it did make her seem self-centered. I don't think that would be the first time she's been portrayed that way, so I don't think anything _you wrote_ was over the top. I can see it as she's been through too much to be able to be full of empathy for others right now; that's ok.
Edit: Also, I'm shocked someone blinded Paul! I did kind of assume it was some automatic magic thing because I didn't see how an accidental thing like that would merit it. Also, it's not like he got a fair trial or anything, this just happened! I'm with theoretical Kraaia - what is WRONG with you people (elves)??
OK, I see your point. Definitely she was cold to not take Cat seriously at the beginning, though Cat is an excitable enough person that it probably takes more than a squeal or two to convince Flann that something is really wrong. (Not that Flann isn't the same way.
)
I didn't think of "No one caught Flann" as a pity-me moment at all though! I had to get her down below Paul's lashes, and so down she went. The fact that there were two guys right there and no one caught her needed a mention, I thought, especially since Aengus caught her earlier when she almost fainted, plus had brains enough to figure out why.
I wonder if that line would have had the same impact if I hadn't put it in a paragraph of its own.
Incidentally I am keeping an eye on Aengus and Flann's interactions. Aengus is attracted to her, as Dante revealed once, and it must be a fairly strong attraction since Dante can't see much of what's going on in Aengus's head in general, and also Aengus frankly had other things on his mind at that instant. And Aengus is not the most morality-encumbered man around, and Flann is an unstable, insecure young lady. Just sayin'. I don't have any homewrecking plans for those two at the moment, but this is the sort of situation where characters write their own stories. An extra glance slips into a paragraph here, a seemingly pointless hand clasp there, and next thing I know...
I mean if the punishment is in some way related to Malcolm leaving the valley. As in, are the two events connected?
And now, with all this talk about blood, I can't help but wonder if maybe Malcolm meant what he said about Rua's blood being on his hands literally
I don't know... I don't know why any elves besides Osh and Rua would care whether Malcolm stays or goes. At this point, nobody but Sigefrith and Cedric and a few guards know Malcolm is gone anyway. And he won't literally make it out of the valley for another hour or two so... even supposing there is some connection between Malcolm and Rua, it hasn't been broken yet.
Malcolm did literally have blood on his hands, at least at one point. In "Cedric makes a promise" I wrote:
The prints, of course, are of Malcolm's own hand. You can just see one of them in this picture.
Of course we don't necessarily know whose blood it is...
Wait- Don't we?!?! Unless Malcolm was injured and we don't know about it... Which doesn't seem likely since we've been looking at him all night long. Or maybe Paul is injured and he went to Nothelm first? Ack! That missing bit of time between when Malcolm started the story and when he took Cubby away is going to drive me bonkers.
EDIT: By the way Lothere, nobody does horror quite like you. I'm still freaked out.
We will get our first tidbit of information about what happened during that time period in the next chapter. (Approximately 1-1/2 hours elapsed between "Malcolm learns the trick of bedtime tales" and "Cedric makes a promise" according to my outline, including at the very least 20 minutes' travel time between Nothelm and the castle.)
As a random side note: It makes me happy that the Irish ladies are taking a bit of interest in their Elven husbands heritage. I had found it a bit unbalanced that the men seemed to be learning more about the ladies heritage. (Also I was hoping to use what they learned for more Elven life tidbits. )
Note two: Yes tons of great plot cliffhangers went down; but a sizable amount of my attention was grabbed by shirt less wonder. Hello, Aengus! feel free to lose your shirt any time!
Desi, this one's for you.
Flann is taking more interest in Osh's heritage than Cat has in Paul's, in fact. Perhaps Cat holds a lot more bitterness against the elves due to their treatment of Paul. Or maybe Cat and Paul are so intensely close that they don't need artificial things like a shared language and culture?
And probably Flann is trying to get closer to Osh in that way -- and Osh seems to find it touching that she's interested, so there's surely some positive feedback there.
Flann is also teaching Gaelic to Osh, which Paul has never seemed to care to learn. (Or Cat has never bothered to teach.)
I've always wondered at couples I've known where one of the spouses never "bothers" to learn the language or learn much about the culture of the other. It's common enough in my experience that I put "bothers" in quotes, since it is apparently not in contradiction with loving somebody. But it seems so OBVIOUS to me that you would want to learn!
So in my world, Paul and Cat are in the "not bothering" camp, and Osh and Flann are in the "teach me everything about you" camp.
I thank you for that pic from the bottom of my heart. Also thank you for pointing that out about the cultural exchange, or lack their of.
Could Osh have done it to Paul? Would he have? If he was so enraged about Lasrua. Did he even have a chance to do it? I guess maybe Sorin did it again while Paul was back getting Madra. Who has the power to actually do that? Maybe it is only Sorin and Saralla.
Imagine how Paul must feel if it was Osh who did it.
And wow that last picture chilled me to the bone.
And can I just ask what is the deal with Osh's attitude to Flann. I found this rather disturbing:
"He crushed her to his chest and made her breathe against his throat in shallow gasps, like a panting bird, until she cried out, and he melted."
I mean, he is kind of suffocating her and I imagine she was crying out in fright. All of this crushing. It reminded me of Radomir and the baby bird
. I feel like Flann and Osh's relationship is so unequal now. Maybe it was equal when they were just chuckle buddies but now it is so Osh who is in charge.
I have been back to read old Flash chapters and... well look... I am going to do it. I finally give up on Team Araphel. I am doing it. I mean... in a sort of half-hearted manner. I still want them for each other but it isn't going to happen and it is clear that Osh and Flann are both miserable with the current situation. Osh is disappointed with the fact she can't be his true elven wife and it is so clear that Flann senses that disappointment even if Osh is hiding it well. She knows he isn't entirely happy with her. So what I am asking is, can't they just, you know, try again with the whole elven marriage thing? Maybe it only didn't work because of Araphel making a visit. I want them to be married "properly" now. Now that I have seen Flann's POV on this... she knows something is wrong, she can sense at least that, and reading back on the chapter where Osh blows up at Paul and talks about lying with Flann like some Kisor slut (man him saying that made me feel sick).
Also, Osh has a beard again.
I do have some concerns with the crushing however. That was a little scary. He shouldn't frighten her like that by doing weird stuff with her breath unless she wants it (I guess maybe she does... although she hasn't seemed to like it before).
And another thing worried me when I went back and read Liadan wins. A lot of that was talking about how she felt like Osh and her were merging, like the boundaries between them were disappearing. I didn't notice it when I read it the first time, but it was all about that, how kissing him was suddenly like kissing herself. What frightened me was that suddenly this paragraph took on a whole new meaning for me:
"She felt her hands tighten around something, and she felt the pain of the tightening grip. She felt a desire to bite and suck. She longed to capture, to crush, to pin down, to penetrate. She wanted to squash any show of strength into helplessness, and to twist any resistance into a plea for further subjugation.
And yet she still felt a need to resist."
Was that Osh?!!! There's that word again... crush. Eeek! Or was it just some hallucination because she was freaking out because he was suffocating her?
Because some of those things I can imagine Osh thinking... biting, sucking penetrating, whatever. What freaked me out was the squashing to helplessness and the subjugation. That doesn't seem like the Osh we know (and some of us love
). It didn't seem like that when we were in his head in Osh is brought beyond such bounds. I mean, he did have something of a disregard for personal air space but I don't think there were so many thoughts about subjugation etc. So what was that?
Btw... there are tonnes of questions in this comment and of course I don't really expect you to answer all (or any) of them. I am just quietly freaking out is all.
Osh's and Flann's "elven marriage" or rather lack thereof is a probable future storyline. They'll have to deal with this in some way. Even if Osh has decided he can live without it, Flann is feeling so insufficient.
Right now they both believe that it is impossible -- that something very bad happened to Osh when they were sort of heading in that direction. (Even though they seemed to get a lot closer in "Liadan wins" and nothing bad happened.) However, the temptation to try again is going to remain there for both of them.
Sexually speaking, Osh has always seemed a little "too much" for Flann. (So did Brude.) Flann tends to cover her fragility with bravado, so it's maybe a little bit her fault. I'm sure when Brude first started groping her and Flann was panicking inside, she was nevertheless acting all casual and like it's no big deal and she has done this before. That's just Flann -- kind of like Hetty, she pretends everything is all right and then opens herself up to more wounds because it really isn't.
I like your "disregard for personal air space" remark.
That is really Osh right there. I think he's too afraid Flann would refuse if he involved her a little more in the decision making, so he just goes ahead. (He also seems to underestimate her ability to even sense what he is doing. He may think she's unaware.)
There's also a certain kinkiness to it. Osh is really turned on by the sounds she makes, so he does what it takes to get her to make a sound. If Flann realized this she might be a lot more vocal and save herself some squeezing.
But maybe Osh also just likes to be rough. I am going to remain ambiguous about that quote you quoted for now: whether she saw Osh's scary dark side, or whether that's just what male sexuality would feel like to a woman feeling it for the first time.
I don't think Flann is repulsed by any of this... she's not forcing herself to like it. But it does scare her a little at times. She probably just needs to be reassured a little. But Osh is so not going to communicate about that.
That's just Osh -- whenever he's afraid he won't like the answer, he simply doesn't ask the question. He's not a bad guy -- the people he loves, he really loves -- but he is sort of oily that way. Dodging questions... slipping unpleasant responsibilities off onto other people (like Sora, who had to wear the pants in the family -- not that it didn't suit her fine)... sneaking out of unpleasant situations rather than facing up to them... patching over problems rather than fixing them... retreating into his world of paints and brushes...
(I actually place some of the blame for the way Paul is now on his upbringing with Osh, post-Sora. Look at the two of them in "Osh sees behind". Sora would have smacked Paul across the room, and Osh is finding excuses for everything. Osh knows how to put his foot down and scare the living crap out of Paul even to this day (e.g. the recent ass-kicking scenario in Alred's study), but he rarely chooses to do it.)
On the one hand, there is this eternal flame of wisdom burning away inside of him, but on the other, he's something of a misanthrope, and he's not the most honorable, reliable guy. He's more of a slinky cat than a trusty old dog. He would be a great husband for a cat person (as Sora was) but perhaps not for someone like Flann who really needs a dog's love right now.
Hmm, I could be waay off the mark here, concerning the return of Paul's blindness but....(please don't beat me off with sticks)
I've had a feeling that it was a temporary measure to begin with. That an elf curse like this, wasn't meant to be broken, simply because it was put in place to teach him (and other offenders) a valuable lesson. He'd already created a heinous crime (or two) anyway, especially with that fiery temper of his.
But now, because of the nature of the scene that unfolded before him. And the fact that he'd actually harmed his sister....
.... perhaps it was this traumatic experience that had sent him back into remission. As far fetched as it may sound, it's not altogether uncommon. But in those days, they'd see it either as witchcraft or as curses etc....
Maybe now he'll realise that some things come at a price. Thanks to his vicious temper, he's going to live permanently in the dark, with only his other senses to guide him.
I hope I'm making sense here, it's still early morning to me LOL.
Show list of Smileys and allowed HTML Tags