Kingdom of Lothere Forum

  • kingdom of lothere
  • forum
  • verso
  • chat

"Creepy, stinky, withered, rasputin-like, interfering, little crawling critters up the spine, vague stink that you can’t locate, demon-employing, angel-enslaving, creepy, creepy, creep!  Keep your hands off the saint!"

– BonnieLaurel (about Myrddin), "Adalbert sees the evil"

Home › Forums › Other Topics › The Site

Lothere Confuzzles The Blog Analyzers

PenelopetheFox's picture

Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 10:19.

So I found these really neat blog analyzers that are supposed to tell you things like the reading level of the blog and the gender of the writer. I don't think they work for this blog at all. Well actually, the writing style one was pretty good. But note that the androgynous person in the picture is a Mac user. Crazy Laugh

Check it out:

Gender Analysis
http://genderanalyzer.com/?url=www.lothere.com

Reading Level
http://www.criticsrant.com/bb/reading_level.aspx

Writing Style
http://www.typealyzer.com/index.php?lang=en

  • The Site
  • Login to post comments
Lothere's picture

Heh, I thought it was going

Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 11:32.

Heh, I thought it was going to be because my blog is back-dated to the 11th century. Very Happy

Interesting analysis. I am INTJ rather than INTP but who knows what my writing style conveys. I would like to know how they perform this deduction, though. What was their training data?

Gender-wise I am not all that surprised to learn I write like a man. I've worked and studied in male-dominated sciences and industries all my life. My friends have mostly all been men. Also the two characters I identify most with in this story are Egelric and Alred. I am not the girliest of girls. But if the success rate of their guesser is to be believed (currently at only 58% success rate) then it's not exactly a meaningful result. Smile

Reading level Junior High! I like that. If I came out at a college-level I would definitely be writing in the Proustian stratosphere of illegibility. However, it may be that my story rates so low on a reading level because I'm writing fiction and not a technical blog.

Interestingly (or perhaps not) my other defunct and non-fictional blog came up with the exact same results.

  • Login to post comments
PenelopetheFox's picture

Wow really? The same

Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 12:07.

Wow really? The same results?

I wonder how these things work as well. There is quite a hefty amount of text on this blog.

The writing style analysis said that I was an extraverted go-getter... Oh if only they knew the depths of my laziness. And I don't really feel like I'm terribly extraverted either.

My boyfriend's politics/entertainment blog came out with a college reading level. Not really surprising since some of the articles are so fully of philosophical rhetoric that they're virtually unreadable.

EDIT: This post was seriously suffering from the missing word syndrome!

  • Login to post comments
Lothere's picture

These things are probably

Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 12:23.

These things are probably relatively dumb (in the artificial intelligence sense) classifiers that just look for commonalities between a given text and a corpus of training texts, without really understanding what they're looking at.

Looking at the gender and the personality type ones, in fact, they admit they are using the uClassify service, which is just that.

Mind you, the more & better training data you give such systems, the more proficient they are at classification, so it's a very interesting and potentially useful research area in computer science.

I am sure they don't read the entire blog to do their analysis, so I do wonder what page or pages they read to get their data. All the posts on the first page? The post summaries only?

I just ran the "what reading level am I?" text on the "Aelfden gives an unexpected answer" page directly, and it came out as Elementary School. I think there's something wrong there... maybe it was the comments that lowered the reading level down to that of 8-year-olds! Laughing

Anyway, if they're using other blogs as their training data then you would expect results for writing of another genre to be fairly useless.

You might play with oFaust.com too, though it's more annoying since you have to copy & paste a text. But if you do then it tries to compare your writing with other authors. I ran that same chapter and got a 22% similarity to LEWIS CARROLL of all people. Along with the whining message: "There is a slight similarity with the works of Lewis Carroll . I am bored, give me more to read, and please higher quality Wink To which I say, oFaust, oFuck You!

  • Login to post comments
Van's picture

These things are never that

Submitted by Van on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 16:42.

These things are never that accurate, but it's fun to see what wrong answers they might come up with.

I ran mine through these, and it correctly guessed that I'm female, but it also said I was ESTP (I'm really INFP) and that my blog's reading level was "Genius" (it is definitely, definitely NOT). I then tried Dragging Blue Lake, which got all the same results that mine got. Might be a Blogger thing. Mhalwae also got a reading level of genius, but they guessed that Verity was a man (which is wrong, if I remember correctly), and then the Typealyzer detected the language as SIMPLIFIED CHINESE. I'm not normally a big fan of internet slang, but WTF? Last time I checked, Mhalwae was most definitely written in English. Saoghal got an elementary school reading level (I personally disagree), but other than that got the same results as Dragging Blue Lake and Kingdom of Naroni.

EDIT: I heartily agree, o'Faust is most certainly EVIL. I just ran it on some of my stuff and it said it was most like the guy who wrote the Wizard of Oz. I hate the Wizard of Oz Sad

  • Login to post comments
PenelopetheFox's picture

At least OFaust didn't tell

Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 22:56.

At least OFaust didn't tell you that you write like Sir Arthur Conan Doyle! Laughing

  • Login to post comments
Van's picture

That is true.

Submitted by Van on Fri, 12/12/2008 - 23:09.

That is true. Smile

  • Login to post comments
Syndicate content

Who's online

There are currently 0 users and 2 guests online.

Recent comments

  • I love that you're out there
    2 years 3 weeks ago
  • If anyone is interessed, I
    2 years 12 weeks ago
  • Tainted as it's been by the
    3 years 15 weeks ago
  • So, so sorry to hear that.
    3 years 15 weeks ago
  • To readers of this story I
    3 years 18 weeks ago
  • It had something to do with
    3 years 39 weeks ago
  • That sounds so fun,
    3 years 39 weeks ago
  • Well, I did made the top
    3 years 40 weeks ago
  • Hello Lothere, Maybe you
    3 years 40 weeks ago
  • Oh, man, I forgot about the
    4 years 25 weeks ago

New forum topics

  • Wawa
  • Works similar to Lothere?
  • Well, Well. Another Year!
  • Sunni
  • Ncaa March Madness
more

Who's new

  • Stephanie
  • Lady Dora
  • Finn

RSS

Syndicate content

User login

  • Request new password

Navigation

  • Image galleries
  • Polls
  • Quotes
  • Recent posts
  • kingdom of lothere
  • forum
  • verso
  • chat