"On the other hand, I still want to jump on the furniture, and he still wants to jump on the pretty girls, so perhaps it was only ever a difference in our personalities."
What kind of peasant chapters?
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 05:43.
More peasant chapters, both old favorites and new
55% (16 votes)
Just more new peasant characters
0% (0 votes)
Just more Gunnilda and other old favorites
31% (9 votes)
No more peasant chapters, the balance is already good
10% (3 votes)
Don't care
3% (1 vote)
Total votes: 29
- Login to post comments
Who's online
There are currently 0 users and 0 guests online.
Recent comments
- I love that you're out there
2 years 2 weeks ago - If anyone is interessed, I
2 years 12 weeks ago - Tainted as it's been by the
3 years 15 weeks ago - So, so sorry to hear that.
3 years 15 weeks ago - To readers of this story I
3 years 18 weeks ago - It had something to do with
3 years 39 weeks ago - That sounds so fun,
3 years 39 weeks ago - Well, I did made the top
3 years 40 weeks ago - Hello Lothere,
Maybe you
3 years 40 weeks ago - Oh, man, I forgot about the
4 years 25 weeks ago
Who's new
- Stephanie
- Lady Dora
- Finn
The last poll clearly shows
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 05:55.The last poll clearly shows a demand for more peasant chapters (about 3/4 of you at this time), but it's not clear how many of you voted +Peasants due to longing for Gunnilda, and how many just because you want MOAR PEASANTS. Hence this clarifying poll.
Now that I have fully populated the valley and begun assigning the "working class" to jobs within the realm of the nobles, I think in any case we will be seeing a lot more glimpses of peasants at least. In so many of my early chapters there is mention of maids and stewards and other characters "coming to the door" or whatever, but we never see them. It's kind of Beauty-and-the-Beast disembodied-hand spooky. But as you've seen with the recent chapter with Gwynn and the dressmaker and Edith the maid, or the several appearances of Derbail and Edina, or even secretaries like Addonwy, I am making an effort to slip those characters in wherever they would realistically be found.
So I would not be surprised if some of those characters end up getting chapters of their own anyway. I did that quite early on in a few chapters with Sigefrith's guards, at the time Druze was discovered. (We figured out Maud died during a romantic encounter between a guard and a maid after all.) It sufficed for me to make their Sims. (And imagine, if I hadn't made the Captain!)
But I guess I want to know whether it's the balance of upper-class/lower-class that's truly wrong, or it's just a case of you missing some of your old favourites.
I liked how you mixed in
Submitted by Sofie on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 11:16.I liked how you mixed in some working class in the "Lena confronts an almighty fear" chapter. My vote is for both old and new, but the new don't have to be totally new characters, but can be more of Colburga, Oswald, Aelfie and and others, whom we've seen before and know a bit of, but don't see very often.
I think if I manage to set
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 11:41.I think if I manage to set up a base of operations in Gunnilda's dining room, we should have plenty of opportunities to revisit some oldies. I just need to bring Gunnilda back into the story in a big way. Then we will have Gunnilda herself, Ethelmund, Colburga and her husband, Aelfie and Osric (how could I forget Aelfie??), and maybe some new ones like Gunnilda's niece the dressmaker.
And the growing-up adventures of Gytha!
And Shirtless Beddy!
That would be perfect!
Submitted by Sofie on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 11:58.That would be perfect!
Yeah I would really like to
Submitted by Devin on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 12:16.Yeah I would really like to see more of the middle class and peasants. Its been so long since we've seen the Ashdowns and Hoggs.
I think that I'd originally
Submitted by Karen on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 12:38.I think that I'd originally voted for no more peasant chapters because the balance is fine, but if you're going to change who shows up in the peasant chapters, then I want to see more Gunnie. I still have hope that she and Egelric will get together one day...or one night, if you know what I mean .
It's not that I don't like
Submitted by Van on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 14:18.It's not that I don't like the idea of new peasants, I just think there's so much going on with so many other characters right now that there's not much room for many new storylines at the current time, and we haven't seen any of those classics like Gunnilda in sooooo long, so if you're planning on introducing a few more storylines in the near future, it would be nice if Gunnilda and Ethelmund were squeezed in.
Of course, if there's no possible way you can do that without interfering with the rest of the story, don't do it.
And I have to agree with Karen, I still firmly believe that Egelric and Gunnilda were made for each other and should eventually get together, live well into their nineties, and die from simultaneous heart attacks spurred on by one last passionate, romantic roll in the sack. That was supposed to be Alred and Matilda's death too, but it's too late for that
die from simultaneous heart
Submitted by Tiffany on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 16:28.die from simultaneous heart attacks spurred on by one last passionate, romantic roll in the sack.
It sounds like the perfect
Submitted by Sofie on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 16:34.It sounds like the perfect death, if it weren't for the fact that I believe heart attacks hurt quite a lot.
True. Okay... how about
Submitted by Van on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 17:18.True.
Okay... how about they die peacefully in their sleep after one last passionate, romantic roll in the sack?
Completely spent.
Submitted by Tiffany on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 17:27.Completely spent.
Is it just me or does the
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 17:32.Is it just me or does the fact that Gunnilda and Egelric never got together make their romance even MOAR romantic? Because this way, there's still all the yearning for what could have been.
*Insert violin solo here*
I agree. However, the whole
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 17:35.I agree. However, the whole thing has completely died off lately, and that's not very romantic at all. What we need is to revive the yearning but never quite satisfy it.
*insert bassoon chorus here*
I guess I'm the only one who
Submitted by Devin on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 17:58.I guess I'm the only one who doesen't really want to see Gunnilda and Egelric together. I always felt that their somewhat affair was wrong; since Alwy was alive and a good husband to Gunnie. I think its been too long, Egelric moved on and fell in love and married 2 other ladies while Gunnie married Ethlemund. I just can't see it happening.
You might be right, Devin.
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 18:09.You might be right, Devin. Egelric might very well have moved on. But that seems so tragic in a way.
They seemed so right together for a while... I don't think we ever saw Egelric that open and vulnerable with any other woman. She was there for him when he was really, really broken. He fixed himself up and -- more importantly -- built a very strong shell around himself afterwards, but for a while he and Gunnilda really met on the same level. His later relationships always seemed tinged with a certain amount of fond indulgence, almost paternal at times, but there was none of that with Gunnilda.
Of course now his relationship with Gunnilda is tinged (not to say tainted) with a class difference. In spite of his fondness for teasing Alred & Co. by lapsing into peasant manners, Egelric is actually turning into something of a snob. Maybe it's not his fault -- that's his world now -- but I am sure Gunnilda feels it.
(Egelric turned into a snob
Submitted by Devin on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 18:18.(Egelric turned into a snob after he married Lili, IMO )
Has he been snobbish towards Gunnilda and her family?
We haven't seen Egelric with
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 18:35.We haven't seen Egelric with Gunnilda and her family since then, so I don't know. I don't think he visits much at all... I can imagine Egelric "visiting Ethelmund" but not dropping by specifically to see Gunnilda. The only time he would have gone to see Gunnilda was if something was wrong with Iylaine and he really didn't know what to do.
They would have met numerous times at Iylaine's house, but that's a little different too. Egelric's not the type who would brag about his wealth or whatnot, but he is the sort who could be stand-offish if he's not among his close friends. And I doubt he considers Gunnilda his "close friend" these days even if she is sort of like Iylaine's foster mother. Gunnilda is someone he was close to, but not his friend nowadays. They must have plenty to talk about in those situations by keeping the conversation on the topic of Iylaine and her babies, but I can imagine the rest of their conversation being the usual polite "how do you like that weather" conversation.
So I think his relationship with Gunnilda is more directly affected by his own stand-offish personality than any "you're not good enough to hang out with me" idea of his. I doubt he looks down on Gunnilda. It's just more like she's not one of "his people" any more -- even though, out of all the people he ever meets -- she's the closest to truly being "his people". I do think Egelric has sort of lost himself over the years, and it has damaged him. He's a bit uprooted and adrift.
As for his snobbery, I think that's just one of Egelric's self-defense mechanisms. He's always looking to make himself prickly (and perhaps make himself stand out... paradoxically), and one way he does it is by being a little high-and-mighty among the peasants, and being a little crass and common among the nobles. That's just Egelric.
Ach, this thread is starting
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 20:38.Ach, this thread is starting to make me sad! Their friendship is so dead. And even if fate kind of pushed them back together, I don't think that it would help their general misery. I'd particularly hate to see Gunnie die a dried-up old spinster with nothing but her memories of youth. But it kinda looks like she's headed there.
It would be kind of
Submitted by Lothere on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 20:45.It would be kind of interesting though. If Gunnilda held on all her life to her dream of Egelric, even though Egelric has moved beyond her. All that yearning... over nothing. Since it's not the story of Gunnilda I could get away with that. She could redeem it -- sort of -- perhaps -- by sharing her experience or wisdom with someone (oh I don't know... FINN???) and convincing him to have the courage to take that extra step she never did.
But I do think Egelric and Gunnilda could still be the sort of couple that finds itself again towards the end of life's journey. When Egelric's all tired out from raging and Gunnilda's kids are all grown and she has no one left to take care of.
EDIT: And remember Marilla? And how she had that secret thing for Gil's father all those years? It would be so poetically right if Gunnilda helped Gwynn and Finn get together...
Who's Marilla? I'm torn
Submitted by Devin on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 21:12.Who's Marilla?
I'm torn between seeing Finn get together with Gwynn or Gytha Hogge. It would be great if Egelric's daughter in-law would be Gunnilda's daughter.
Marilla is a character from
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 21:31.Marilla is a character from Anne of Green Gables, Devin.
But that was totally different! We never got to actually SEE them courting so there wasn't the same kind of attachment to the idea of them being together for those of us who are outside of the world of the story peeking in.
Also, Marilla brought that one on herself.
OMG I completely forgot
Submitted by Devin on Fri, 01/09/2009 - 21:35.OMG I completely forgot about her. Prince Edward Island.
That would almost be a
Submitted by Lothere on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 06:17.That would almost be a little spooky if Finn and Gytha got together, but I guess that would be a still more Anne-like ending than if it were Gwynn. On the other hand, Gunnilda was Gwynn's wet nurse, so they have a very close bond too. Gwynn used to call her Mama Gunnie.
Also, if Gunnilda's daughter and Egelric's son got married, that would definitely shut the door on Gunnilda and Egelric ever getting together, and like I said, it's not quite too late.
Anyway Gwynn and Finn are themselves sufficient argument against that. Gwynn and Finn! I don't usually get so far ahead of myself, but IT HAS TO BE!
But he's so ugly and rude
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 06:30.But he's so ugly and rude and smelly and his eyes aren't violet! He's the least erotic boy in all of the valley!
How I hope she tells him
Submitted by Lothere on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 06:33.How I hope she tells him that to his face!
I wonder how long he'll
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 06:35.I wonder how long he'll continue to let her use the word "erotic" incorrectly. I would love it if he were the person to finally break it to her.
That could be delicious.
Submitted by Lothere on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 06:40.That could be delicious. What could be still more fun is if Finn himself doubted his English rather than assuming she was using the word incorrectly, and then started using the word the way she does. WITH HER. For YEARS. And then someday someone breaks the news to both of them.
Alternatively, he decides his English is correct, but assumes Gwynn knows exactly what she's talking about and never thinks of verifying or correcting her. Not erotic? I can be erotic!
Haha! And then he follows it
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 06:50.Haha! And then he follows it up with a display of the same. That would show her.
But it seems like if Finn started using the word incorrectly, someone would eventually take him aside. I get the feeling that the only reason why no one has corrected Gwynn yet is simply because she's Gwynn. hehehehe Boy would it be hilarious if that went on for like 20 years.
There was a recent episode of This American Life that was dedicated to erroneous facts that the interviewees thought were true well into their adult years. The one that sticks out in my mind the most was the woman who thought that unicorns were real but extinct.
I just come back from London
Submitted by François on Thu, 01/15/2009 - 03:46.I just come back from London and I see I missed a new poll ! So, my point is that I'd love to see new characters as maids point of view or like when Young Sigefrith went to Mouse's house (what about her brothers and sister ?). It's more the relation between peasant and noble men that I miss, since it was constant in middle age (like in the market).
Like I said before in comments, it would be very interesting to have the point of views of the lower class working around our bunch of nobles. Because they might have a very accurate or very false impression of the people they're working for. And if there were a new peasant family like Gunnilda's one or a few chapters about Alwy's children, I wouldn't complain, too.
But it's your story and you have so many plots and things to achieve : the elves, the prophecy, the war, William the Conqueror (I took picture of the Tower of London and Middle Age stuff in London for you but I don't know how to post pictures on the forum), the Scot's mystery, who Gwynn will marry, Iylaine/Finn mystery, Liadan mystery, Leofric non-supposed-to-be-living-and-all-the-stuff-going-around-that, Blocky (who isn't very mysterious, but so funny anyway), Egelric destiny, the Norse men, will Caedwulf and Ogive marry and the look of their children, the Drage/Middrin mystery, the demons/Hell/Theobald mystery, The Will-Vash-Ever-Get-A-Girl Mystery (a great one deserving caps), the destiny of your French characters (especially if crooked noses, I follow the destiny of the French you don't have killed ^^), the Aelfden mystery, the Will-There-Be-A-Cruisade mystery, the Will-Gwynn-Ever-Goes-To-Wales mystery (ok, that's two mysteries for Gwynn, but she's very mysterious, isn't she :p ), the Will-Yusuf-Ever-Marry Mystery, the Andokrinos mystery, and so many ones, but I'll spent afternoon to write all them down. I don't know how you do not to get lost in all of this. So if you can add a little peasant even non-mystery thing, that would be awesome.
~Your French Friend~
François you are hilarious.
Submitted by Lothere on Thu, 01/15/2009 - 05:09.François you are hilarious. You also remind me just how much I have going on in this story and I suddenly feel rather overwhelmed.
Oh no Meryt don't feel
Submitted by Devin on Thu, 01/15/2009 - 09:48.Oh no Meryt don't feel overwhelmed because then your not going to enjoy writing Lothere. Just take things 1 step at a time; and the elves can be written during the summer or fall of 1086.
I am afraid I am going to
Submitted by Lothere on Thu, 01/15/2009 - 10:03.I am afraid I am going to have to do the big elf drama at the end of the year as originally planned. I have several other related things coming together at that time, so I will lose some of the drama if I hold it off till later.
Oh well, at least that way we should be getting lots of Shus.
Did somebody say Shus???
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Thu, 01/15/2009 - 18:32.Did somebody say Shus???
What, no ?
Submitted by Lothere on Thu, 01/15/2009 - 18:34.What, no ?
How could I have forgoted?
Submitted by PenelopetheFox on Sun, 01/18/2009 - 15:22.How could I have forgoted?
I'm so late in posting in
Submitted by stacysaurus on Thu, 01/29/2009 - 20:37.I'm so late in posting in this topic... I'd really like to see more Wynna and Anson. I guess not soon or anything... but Anson really intrigues me because it seems like he has some big plans. So I'm very curious where that little family may be headed.
The Adventures of Anson is a
Submitted by Lothere on Thu, 01/29/2009 - 21:07.The Adventures of Anson is a topic that I am saving for a slow period in the story, since it's not really tied to anything else in the timeline. I do have plans for him! But I am really trying to get things moving again. But then again I didn't realize there were any Anson "fans" out there.
Anson? I could get down with
Submitted by Tiffany on Fri, 02/20/2009 - 19:51.Anson? I could get down with that!
More peasant chapters, both
Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 04/22/2009 - 09:54.More peasant chapters, both old favorites and new...but if time /writing constrains are an issue just more Gunnida. I miss her.